Amusement Parks
The Legendary Pizza Trio
The Legendary Pizza Trio - Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana, Sally's Apizza, and Modern Apizza
New Haven is renowned for many things and, among them, its pizza holds a special place in the hearts and taste buds of locals and visitors alike. The city boasts a rich pizza culture, with three iconic establishments that have become culinary landmarks: Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana, Sally's Apizza, and Modern Apizza. Each of these pizzerias brings its unique flavor and history to the table, making the Elm City a destination for pizza enthusiasts.
So let's go Nutmegging: Pepe's, Sally's and Modern!
Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana:
Established in 1925 by Frank Pepe, this pizzeria is often credited with introducing Neapolitan-style pizza to the United States. Located one block from beautiful Wooster Square, Pepe's has maintained its original coal-fired brick oven, imparting a distinctive charred crust to its pies. The white clam pizza, topped with fresh clams, garlic, olive oil, oregano, and grated cheese, is an iconic dish that has become a symbol of Pepe's culinary excellence. The simplicity of their ingredients and dedication to tradition has earned Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana a spot among the nation's best pizzerias.
Pepe's, 157 Wooster Street,203.865.5762, https://pepespizzeria.com/
Sally's Apizza
Sally's Apizza, another Wooster Street staple, opened its doors in 1938. Founded by Salvatore "Sally" Consiglio, Sally's is becoming a big business, with locations opening throughout Connecticut and Massachusetts. The original New Haven location still has the feeling of a family-owned establishment and continues using the original Sally recipes and techniques. The pizza at Sally's is distinguished by its thin crust and high-quality ingredients. Their classic tomato pie, with a savory sauce and a sprinkle of Pecorino Romano cheese, is a local favorite. The no-frills ambiance and commitment to preserving the original recipes contribute to Sally's enduring charm and popularity. And talk about popular: Sally's was Frank Sinatra's favorite New Haven destination. When Vice President Kamala Harris was in New Haven to deliver a speech, she ordered pies from Sally's for her entourage and Secret Service detail. During the early days of the Doonesbury comic strip Mike Doonesbury, Zonker, B.D. and the gang hung out at Sally's. Now that's pedigree!
Sally's, 237 Wooster Street, 203.624.5271,
https://sallysapizza.com/locations/new-haven/
Modern Apizza (and, for what it’s worth, David Mayhew’s personal favorite!):
Not far from its historic counterparts, Modern Apizza on State Street offers a more contemporary take on the New Haven pizza scene. Established in 1934, Modern Apizza blends tradition with innovation. Their thin-crust pies are known for their generous toppings and a wide array of flavor combinations. The Italian Bomb, featuring bacon, sausage, pepperoni, mushroom, onion, pepper, and garlic, is a testament to their commitment to bold and diverse flavors. Modern Apizza's dedication to quality and creativity has earned it a devoted following, making it a must-visit for those seeking a modern twist on the classic New Haven slice.
Modern, 874 State Street, 203.776.5306, https://modernapizza.com/
APIZZA? HUH? WHY NOT JUST PIZZA?
First of all, it must be pronounced properly. Ah-beets. Pronounce it any other way and people will know you're from somewhere else. Apizza is a decendant of Neapolitan pizza, thin-crust and traditionally baked in a coal-fired oven. The coal gives the crust a smoky flavor and the high heat gives the bottom of the crust a coating of soot. Don't you dare call it burned. You'll be banished. It's charred, not burned. The charred crust enhances the flavor. One more clue: if you want mozzarella on the pie you ask for "mootz." These are New Haven pizza rules.
New Haven's pizza culture is a rich tapestry woven with the history and flavors of Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana, Sally's Apizza, and Modern Apizza. Whether you savor the authenticity of Pepe's, the timeless recipes of Sally's, or the modern interpretations of Modern Apizza, one thing is certain – a visit to these pizzerias is not just a meal; it's an experience that pays homage to the culinary heritage America's pizza capital (yes, pizza capital…my humble opinion).
CONGRESSIONAL RECORD
Connecticut is the pizza capitol of America! Don't take my word for it...this is according to the Congressional Record in May 2024. So there, New York City!
Contribute to the nutmeggery! Do you have a favorite pizza joint aside from the big three in New Haven? Share it with me: dmayhew@hpearce.com.
Lobster Rolls!
IN SEARCH OF THE MOST DECADENT LOBSTER ROLLS...LET'S GO NUTMEGGING!
According to the Encyclopedia of American Food and Drink the lobster roll originated as a hot dish at a restaurant named Perry's in Milford, Connecticut, as early as 1929. Initially, its popularity spread up and down the Connecticut coast, but not far beyond it. Today lobster rolls, with their accompanying potato chips and dill pickles, are popular throughout New England and parts of Canada, particularly the Maritimes.
A lobster roll isn’t just a meal; it’s an escape to a coastal paradise with every delicious bite. Dive into a lobster roll at any of my favorite places. I’ve had lobster rolls at each of the following and I have the extra poundage to prove it. So let's go nutmegging from west (East Haven) to east (Noank):
The Lobster Shack
This small, no-frills spot is famous for its generous portions of fresh lobster meat served hot with melted butter or cold with mayo. The Lobster Shack’s waterfront location enhances the dining experience.
https://www.lobstershackct.com/
3 Cosey Beach Ave, East Haven, CT 06512, 203.483.8314
Lenny & Joe’s Fish Tale
Known for its fresh seafood, Lenny & Joe's offers a classic hot buttered lobster roll that is a favorite among locals and visitors. The casual atmosphere and consistently good food make it a must-visit. Both locations are on the Boston Post road, so no water views. But the Madison location features a small carousel for the kids!
https://www.ljfishtale.com/
1301 Boston Post Rd, Madison, CT 06443, 203.245.7289
86 Boston Post Rd, Westbrook, CT 06498, 860.669.0767

The Clam Castle

A local favorite, The Clam Castle is hardly a castle. It’s more of a roadside joint (no water views here). It’s a tiny place with offering hot buttered lobsters rolls and a quirky menu including Mexican specialties.
https://clamcastlect.com/
1324 Boston Post Rd, Madison, CT 06443, 203.245.4911
The Lobster Landing (My personal favorite!!!)
Don’t look for a restaurant, look for a shack. Yes, a shack right next to a marina. Looks aren’t everything, but flavor is. Lobster Landing is celebrated for its hot, buttery, totally decadent lobster rolls. The charming setting and friendly service make it a popular spot.
https://lobsterlandingct.com/
152 Commerce St, Clinton, CT 06413, 860.669.2005
Liv’s Shack
Another shack, and not afraid to call itself a shack, is Liv’s Shack, nestled by the water in a marina and renowned for its warm lobster rolls served with a touch of lemon butter. If you really want to pack on some extra pounds consider a side of Liv’s truffle fries, gooey fried Wisconsin cheese curds served with house made chipotle aioli.
https://www.livsshack.com/
Harbor One Marina, 26 Bridge St, Old Saybrook, CT 06475, 860.391.8353

Abbott’s Lobster in the Rough

A seasonal outdoor eatery with scenic waterfront views, Abbott’s serves hot buttered lobster rolls brimming with succulent lobster meat. The relaxed ambiance and picturesque setting add to the experience. Abbott’s has a sister restaurant nearby, Costello’s. Get it? Get it? Abbott and Costello? I knew you’d get it.
https://www.abbottslobster.com/
117 Pearl St, Noank, CT 06340, 860.536.7719
Ford’s Lobster
Offering a unique twist on the classic lobster roll, Ford’s features variations like the Lobster Bomb, a scooped out bread bowl overflowing with fresh pink tail and claw meat. That’s all there is to it…but it is da bomb! A must have. Ford’s waterfront location provides a serene backdrop for an explosive meal.
https://www.fordslobster.com/
15 Riverview Ave, Noank, CT 06340, 860.536.2842
These spots offer some of the best lobster rolls along the Connecticut shoreline, each with its unique charm and flavors.
Contribute to the nutmeggery! Have a favorite joint for Lobster Rolls along the Connecticut shoreline? Let me know about it: dmayhew@hpearce.com
Doctor Doolittle in Killingworth
TALKING TO THE ANIMALS IN KILLINGWORTH
Nutmegging around the state recently took me to a quiet country lane in Killingworth where I made this video about a well-known former owner of this early 19th century farmhouse. Take 3 minutes out of your day to enjoy.
Off the Beaten Path: Florence Griswold & Lyman Allyn Museums
Museum Nutmegging: Exploring Two Hidden Gem Museums in Connecticut - The Florence Griswold Museum and Lyman Allyn Art Museum
![]() |
Nutmegging around the Nutmeg State one finds that it is full of incredible cultural spots, but some of my absolute favorite museums are the ones that don’t always make the typical travel lists. If you’re looking for art, history, and a little bit of magic without the crowds, the Florence Griswold Museum in Old Lyme and the Lyman Allyn Art Museum in New London are perfect destinations. And because I like a good day trip with a mix of indoor and outdoor fun, I’ve divided this into ideas for both winter and warm-weather visits!
Winter Adventures: Cozy Museum Days & Nearby Treats
Florence Griswold Museum – Old Lyme
Winter is the perfect time to wander through the Florence Griswold Museum’s beautiful historic home and art galleries without the summer rush. In the early 1900s in order to make ends meet, “Miss Florence” turned her home into a boarding house. The arrival of one artist led to more artists, American Impressionists, to make Miss Florence’s home their destination for the warmer months, for en plein air painting and for hi-jinks. Miss Florence would invite them to paint murals on the doors of their rooms, but did she really want them to paint murals throughout her formal dining room? The paintings are still there and there’s something magical about seeing the hand-painted doors inside Miss Florence’s house while looking out at a snowy landscape. Click to visit the website.
![]() |
Winter Extras:
- Visit Krieble Gallery at the Florence Griswold Museum for their changing seasonal exhibitions through each year.
- Head over to the Old Lyme Inn for late afternoon tea or an early dinner.
- Stick around after dinner to pop into the Side Door Jazz Club at the Inn, hailed by Downbeat magazine as one of the best jazz spots in the country.
Lyman Allyn Art Museum – New London
For a classic winter museum day, the Lyman Allyn Art Museum is a fantastic choice. This under-the-radar gem houses a wonderful collection of American and European art, plus thought-provoking contemporary exhibitions. The historic mansion setting adds an extra layer of charm, and their special exhibitions always surprise me.
Winter Extras:
- Grab a coffee and lunch at Muddy Waters CafĂ© – A New London staple with an inviting, warm vibe and delicious pastries.
- Visit the Garde Arts Center – If you time it right, you might catch a film or live performance at this beautifully restored 1920s theater.
- Check out the Custom House Maritime Museum – If you love maritime history, this small but fascinating museum offers a great indoor complement to your Lyman Allyn visit.
Warm-Weather Escapes: Art, Gardens, and Coastal Strolls
Florence Griswold Museum – Old Lyme
When the weather is warm, the Florence Griswold Museum truly comes alive! The gardens burst into color, and you can stroll along the Lieutenant River, imagining the painters who once set up their easels along its banks. Don’t forget to bring a sketchbook if you’re feeling inspired!
Warm-Weather Extras:
- Explore the Florence Griswold's gardens and seasonal outdoor sculpture trail – This path winds through the museum grounds, offering a mix of nature and art
- Take a walk in the nearby Roger Tory Peterson Estuary Center – A beautiful spot to soak in the coastal environment. Better yet: visit Black Hall Outfitters and rent a kayak to explore! My favorite is the pedal-drive kayak, but take your pick.
- Lunch at the charming Old Lyme Inn – A historic setting with delicious seasonal fare.
Lyman Allyn Art Museum – New London
A warm day makes the Lyman Allyn Art Museum even better because you can pair your visit with outdoor adventures. Their sculpture-filled gardens are wonderful to explore, and New London’s proximity to the coast means you can easily add a seaside stroll to your itinerary.
Warm-Weather Extras:
- Walk through Harkness Memorial State Park – This stunning park in nearby Waterford offers ocean views, beautiful gardens, and a mansion to admire from the outside.
- If you’re lucky and it’s open, check out Monte Cristo Cottage, the boyhood home of playwright Eugene O’Neill and the home that inspired his classic plays Ah! Wilderness! and Long Day’s Journey Into Night.
- Head to Ocean Beach Park – If it’s a particularly warm day, why not dip your toes in the sand after your museum visit?
- Dinner at Tony D’s – One of my personal favorites! An excellent spot in New London for Italian food and a relaxed, welcoming atmosphere.
Why I Love These Museums & Why They Deserve a Visit By You
Both the Florence Griswold Museum and Lyman Allyn Art Museum offer rich cultural experiences without the overwhelming crowds of bigger institutions. Whether it’s a winter retreat into warm, art-filled spaces or a summer escape filled with coastal beauty and creativity, these museums (and their surroundings) make for unforgettable day trips. I’d love to hear if you’ve visited either—or if you want to share your favorite off-the-beaten-path museum: dmayhew@hpearce.com.